· Updated

Small on purpose

Why I don’t think every online community should be trying to get bigger, and what I want Loudtake to do about it.

Some of the best rooms I’ve been in online were tiny. A few dozen people, mostly the same ones every day. Nobody was trying to grow it. Nobody was measuring it.

Then it got noticed, or someone decided it needed to be bigger, and it slowly stopped being the thing I liked. It didn’t blow up. It just got thinner.

I’ve thought about that a lot while building Loudtake.

Bigger isn’t the same as better

Most platforms treat growth like the only direction. More members, more posts, more reach. Every community inside them gets quietly pulled the same way, whether it wanted to or not.

But a place that works at forty people doesn’t automatically work at four thousand. The things that made it good (people recognizing each other, a shared sense of what’s normal, being able to just talk) don’t scale on their own. They usually get replaced by rules, ranking, and cleanup.

That’s a trade some communities want to make. Plenty don’t. And right now almost nobody gets asked.

What I want instead

I want a place to be able to stay small and have that count as a good outcome. Not a stage on the way to something else. Not a failed community that never took off.

If a room wants to grow, it should be able to, and it should be the people inside who decide that. Not an algorithm, and not a number somebody wants to see go up.

I’m not going to lay out how that works yet. That part is still being worked out, and some of it I’d rather show than describe. What I’ll say is the starting posture: Loudtake communities begin small, and getting bigger is something a place chooses, not something that happens to it.

Why say this now

Because it shapes what I build first and what I leave out. A product designed around growth looks very different from one designed around belonging somewhere. I’d rather say which one I’m making before there’s anything to confuse it with.

If that sounds like the kind of place you’d want to be early to, you can request an invite. If you’d rather just follow along, the notes are here, and the last one is a good companion to this.